FLASH 6:33pm: FINAL - Rossi wins by 261!
FLASH 5:44pm: Grays Harbor reported on their website. (Now added to Sec. of State site).
FLASH 3:59pm: King County reported a smaller than expected lead to Gregoire. The rows in the table below (starting with 3:59pm) are net of the King County report. Unless there are more uncounted ballots in King, Rossi is still on track to win.
* Rossi leads by 19.
* Observers estimate that King County will widen Gregoire's lead by 700.
* From the 5,100 uncounted ballots outside of King County, I projected that Rossi would get a net gain of 730 -- with 775 from the Rossi counties less 45 from the Gregoire counties.
King County is sufficiently large and its reports have been more variable than the other counties. This table shows reports from outside of King County and will be updated throughout the day until King County reports. All of these projections and estimates of uncounted ballots in this table are exclusive of King County. Numbers in red with a + sign favor Rossi, numbers in green with a - sign favor Gregoire. UPDATE: I've changed the table, as I realized some of the columns in the earlier version may have been confusing.
| Time | Rossi's Current Lead |
Rossi's |
Rossi's |
Beating Projections? |
Today's Rossi County Lead |
Rossi County Votes Remaining |
Today's Gregoire County Lead |
Gregoire County Votes Remaining |
Counties Reporting |
| Tuesday end of day |
+19
|
+752
|
0
|
0
|
3,426
|
0
|
1,701
|
||
|
Wednesday
9:30am |
+64
|
+704
|
+45
|
-52
|
+45
|
3,141
|
0
|
1,701
|
Columbia Garfield |
|
10:33am |
+67
|
+700
|
+48
|
-55
|
+48
|
3,121
|
0
|
1,701
|
Lincoln |
|
10:59am |
+36
|
+676
|
+17
|
-89
|
+40
|
3,010
|
23
|
1,556
|
Adams Ferry Pierce Thurston |
|
11:27am |
+112
|
+715
|
+93
|
-41
|
+118
|
2,885
|
25
|
1,546
|
Clallam Jefferson Lewis Pend Oreille Snohomish |
|
11:38am |
+156
|
+741
|
+137
|
-16
|
+162
|
2,735
|
25
|
1,546
|
Grant |
|
11:51am |
+156
|
+738
|
+137
|
-19
|
+166
|
2,715
|
29
|
1,496
|
Chelan Pacific |
|
12:31pm |
+162
|
+744
|
+143
|
-13
|
+172
|
2,713
|
29
|
1,496
|
Asotin |
|
12:34pm |
+133
|
+751
|
+114
|
-9
|
+172
|
2,713
|
58
|
1,346
|
San Juan |
|
12:53pm |
+137
|
+741
|
+118
|
-15
|
+176
|
2,665
|
58
|
1,346
|
Kittitas |
|
1:31pm |
+188
|
+778
|
+169
|
+21
|
+227
|
2,465
|
58
|
1,346
|
Skagit |
|
1:50pm |
+187
|
+776
|
+168
|
+19
|
+226
|
2,455
|
58
|
1,346
|
Spokane |
|
2:36pm |
+197
|
+775
|
+178
|
+18
|
+236
|
2,300
|
58
|
1,346
|
Mason Wahkiakum Yakima Klickitat |
|
3:01pm |
+203
|
+782
|
+184
|
+25
|
+225
|
2,200
|
41
|
1,246
|
Snohomish |
|
3:48pm |
+405
|
+830
|
+386
|
+68
|
+427
|
1,600
|
41
|
1,246
|
Stevens |
|
3:59pm |
-29
|
+369*
|
+398
|
+52
|
+439
|
1,500
|
41
|
1,246
|
King |
|
4:28pm |
-34
|
+348*
|
+393
|
+31
|
+440
|
1,300
|
47
|
1,221
|
Clark |
|
4:49pm |
-28
|
+351*
|
+399
|
+34
|
+446
|
1,250
|
47
|
1,221
|
Skamania |
|
5:14pm |
+4
|
+360*
|
+431
|
+42
|
+478
|
1,000
|
47
|
1,221
|
Whitman |
|
5:23pm |
+92
|
+361*
|
+519
|
+40
|
+566
|
750
|
47
|
1,221
|
Franklin |
|
5:44pm |
-13
|
+264*
|
+414
|
-57
|
+566
|
750
|
152
|
0
|
Grays Harbor |
|
FINAL 6:33pm |
+261
|
+261*
|
+688
|
-68
|
+840
|
0
|
152
|
0
|
Benton |
UPDATE: I heard from another observer of the King County vote count.
He reports that the last of those “extra” ballots seem to be legitimate. According to the observer many of the ballots had signature problems of some variety and had been put aside awaiting resolution such as follow-up verification from the voter. Others were from the canvassing board where they had been sent for a decision on the voter’s intent in marking, or mis-marking the ballot.
The observer said he was confident that there is not fraud involved, just incompetence in the management of the King County elections office. He believes that the office could have tracking counts that would give much more accurate information during the process if they had any interest in doing so.
A direct quote:
I wonder if the election officials even realize that missing an estimate by 100 % puts the whole process in doubt? From what I’ve seen of the process this year, I'm convinced our election system is ripe for fraud from the registration process right through to the ballot processing. Someone, someday, will take advantage of that.As I said before, I would be very reluctant to allege an organized conspiracy of fraud, and I certainly haven't seen any evidence of such a thing. But there does seem to be a lot of sloppiness in the process. And it wouldn't surprise me if there were a non-trivial number of individuals who are taking advantage of the lack of adequate controls. Posted by Stefan Sharkansky at November 17, 2004 10:29 AM | Email This
Everyone was talking about your work last night. We missed your input. Hope to see you next time.
Posted by: Al Hedstrom on November 17, 2004 11:05 AM2) the 1059 update is weird. How is it possible for Gregoire to expand the extent to which she beats expectations, but for Rossi's non-King expected margin of victory to grow?
Thanks for doing this, by the way.
Posted by: DJW on November 17, 2004 11:28 AMEspecially in counties with mail in punch card voting. Many simply do not get the famous chad all the way removed from the ballot. Everytime the ballot goes thru the machine more will fall out. In a hand count there is the possiblilty for significant votes to be found.
The final outcome could very well be determined by which counties use punch card and who they favor. The mail punch card counties will have more significant change, voters not punching straight down etc.
Spectator
Clallam
Island
Mason
Thurston
Pacific
Lewis
Clark
Whatcom
Okanogan
Stevens
Lincoln
Benton
Franklin
Asotin
Most of these are heavily Rossi counties.
All the remaining counties use optical scan ballots, except that Snohomish and Yakima use electronic computers at the polling places.
In a machine recount, hanging chads on a punch card ballot may or may not fall off. Dimpled chads will be missed entirely and not get counted.
In Florida in 2000, Bush and Gore supporters were equally likely to be less forceful in punching their ballots. Gore gained votes from the hand count, because they were done in counties that he had carried heavily.
With machine counting, absentee and provisional optical scan ballots that are marked improperly are noticed, and have already been duplicated and remarked. Polling place ballots have not been, and will be noticed and remarked/duplicated in a machine recount.
However, a machine recount will not do much to improve problems with punch card ballots. Only a hand count will do so.
I am thinking that the election will be closer than 150 votes today, and that a hand recount will be ordered.
If not, there may be an equal protection violation, since a machine recount is much more likely to notice and improve improperly marked ballots in Gregoire areas (i.e. King County) that use optical ballots, than in Rossi areas (i.e. Lewis, Clark, Benton, Franklin, etc.) that use punch card ballots.
It may come down to having to pay for a hand count in the Rossi counties that use punch card ballots.
Posted by: Richard on November 17, 2004 12:32 PMUnlike some of y'all, I'll resist the temptation to assume this is a sign of GOP shenanigans. It should boost Rossi by over 100 votes though. Damn.
Posted by: DJW on November 17, 2004 12:34 PMThe projection was that Gregoire would get 45 votes total in her counties, but she actually has 58 already, with a lot of votes still to count.
Obviously, King remains the wild card since we haven't seen any new totals.
Is this the current state of play?
Thanks.
Rossi is a little short of earlier projections both in "his" counties and in Gregoire's counties. But those projections were never expected to be all that precise, and the current 15 vote difference out of 1,292 cast is about 1.2%.
The other thing to realize is that Gregoire's earlier lead in "her" counties has been very slim. 91% of those uncounted Gregoire county votes are in Grays Harbor, which she's winning only by 0.19% (that would give her a pick up of only 10 votes if that margin held). On the other hand, even ignoring the doubly-counted batch that was corrected, Rossi has still held the lead in the late counted Grays Harbor votes. Nevertheless, the simple model I'm using gives Gregoire a small pick up from those votes.
The real answer: Who knows?
Posted by: Stefan Sharkansky on November 17, 2004 01:10 PMOther states would, but here ??? Who can answwr that question, please?
Posted by: leaddog2 on November 17, 2004 01:34 PMThis is definitely close. I wonder with the number of votes remaining so low if we can count on statistics to hold? I mean, saying one canidate has has being taking 60% of the votes in a county doesn't really mean 6 of the next 10 votes go to that canidate. It seems to me it really is any ones guess at this point who will win.
Posted by: Jack Richins on November 17, 2004 01:40 PM"In Florida in 2000, Bush and Gore supporters were equally likely to be less forceful in punching their ballots. Gore gained votes from the hand count, because they were done in counties that he had carried heavily."
In my opinion -- an opinion shared by John Fund -- the gains made by Gore in the recounts were not attributable to anything so innocent. Two examples: In the first recount, Palm Beach county supposedly put the same punch cards through the same machines and gained about 500 votes for Gore. This is completely implausible. In the second recount, Broward gained about 500 as well, by counting ballots that had never been accepted in Florida before and by using different standards for Bush and Gore votes. Democrat Bob Kerrey, after seeing one of the "votes" they counted, said he couldn't see it, and retreated from the scene.
Several people have done statistical tests on the gains for Gore in the recounts. Results differ, but typically they find a million to one odds against the Gore gains in the recounts being legitimate.
Posted by: Jim Miller on November 17, 2004 01:42 PMDino is now above projections!!! Thank you Grant and Skagit for coming up big today so far!!
Posted by: gustafm on November 17, 2004 01:44 PMAnd yes, that was a nice Skagit boost! Come on Benton...
Posted by: Chris on November 17, 2004 01:47 PMQuestion. Between the 12:53 update and the 1:31 update, the two canidates gained a total of 585 votes. Yet, on your grid, the number of Rossi county votes still to count only declined by 200 while the votes to count in the Gregoire counties did not decline. Shouldn't the increase in the vote totals equal the decline in the number of votes left to count? What am I missing here? Great work, though - much appreciated.
Posted by: The Mose on November 17, 2004 01:53 PMIt incorporates yesterday's Grays Harbor recount.
Posted by: Stefan Sharkansky on November 17, 2004 01:54 PMNot necessarily. The "votes left to count" is only an estimate and it is an estimate that is revised from time to time. The report of actual gubernatorial votes may vary quite a bit from earlier estimates of uncounted ballots. For a number of reasons -- the number of ballots that are actually counted may be different from the estimate. Plus, not all ballots that are counted contain a vote for either of the major gubernatorial candidates.
Posted by: Stefan Sharkansky on November 17, 2004 01:57 PMGo Wahkiakum County...found a few extra there. Just a few.
Posted by: Chris on November 17, 2004 02:26 PMTo all Ds: you'll sue if Gregoire ends up behind.
To all: there is no difference (neither side is more adept at stealing/cheating than the other).
Whomever sues will say they want all votes to count or all legitimate votes to count. BS. They want their candidate to win. I wish they would just admit it. It's not about fairness in any sense. It's MY CANDIDATE TO WIN at all costs.
Except, unfortunately, running the state.
Posted by: Timothy on November 17, 2004 02:56 PMEverybody does it, blah, blah, blah...
Stefan, great site. Thanks.
I just hope I don't live to regret this.
Posted by: Josef on November 17, 2004 03:13 PMThanks for all your efforts.
Posted by: Randy on November 17, 2004 03:33 PMAs of 3:01pm the SoS shows the following:
Christine Gregoire Democrat 1368369 48.86%
Dino Rossi Republican 1368572 48.87%
Ruth Bennett Libertarian 63171 2.25%
Isn't Rossi ahead by only 203 votes?
Posted by: sploosh on November 17, 2004 03:33 PMMaybe Bobbi's going to sport a new shade of eye shadow? ....Oh, I'm being mean. Stop me!
Posted by: Matt on November 17, 2004 03:35 PMThanks for the great work on this site.
Posted by: Spivey on November 17, 2004 03:38 PMand benton will report to put rossi back up?
or does king county have more out there?
Posted by: Ray on November 17, 2004 04:07 PMhttp://vote.wa.gov/general/status.aspx
Posted by: Steve on November 17, 2004 04:10 PMHere is the SOS link Brian.
Posted by: Marc on November 17, 2004 04:11 PMHonestly, I think the 500 more votes are yet to come. It's possible the Republican who is in charge of King County elections wants to amp up the drama of these ballots being recovered. By reporting them at the very last, they are emphasized and made to seem unusual and special. They are unusual and special, but, damn it, these people voted.
Posted by: X on November 17, 2004 04:16 PMHonestly, I think the 500 more votes are yet to come. It's possible the Republican who is in charge of King County elections wants to amp up the drama of these ballots being recovered. By reporting them at the very last, they are emphasized and made to seem unusual and special. They are unusual and special, but, damn it, these people voted.
Posted by: X on November 17, 2004 04:16 PMdoes that make gregoire the winner?
benton's don't count?
it says 4pm on the sec of state website
Posted by: Ray on November 17, 2004 04:20 PMKind Regards, Michael F.
Posted by: Michael on November 17, 2004 04:28 PMThis is proving the addage--All politics are local.
Posted by: Matt on November 17, 2004 04:31 PMCan anyone say "hanging chad"?
Posted by: Brian Emanuels on November 17, 2004 04:48 PMhttp://www.co.benton.wa.us/cgi-bin/wwwquery/election/showresults.qry?RACE=:Next%20Update:
I have Rossi only winning by ~50 votes!
So don't celebrate yet Rossi fans .....
"I also heard that Grays Harbor will report a 277 vote win for Gregoir, ..."
Posted by Brian Emanuels at November 17, 2004 04:48 PM
Are you assuming a 277 vote win from just the remaining ballots or for the total win, which is already at +164 for Gregoire?
If the total win in Grays Harbor is 277, I still have a Rossi win of ~250.
Posted by: bp on November 17, 2004 05:16 PMI mean, really. If you believe this then you must think that the GOP is run by illiterate idiots who don't know what the hell they're voting on.
And I think we're looking at the dreaded hand recount, folks.
Posted by: dw on November 17, 2004 05:28 PMhttp://blogs.msdn.com/jrule/archive/2004/11/12/256794.aspx
Posted by: Jeremy on November 17, 2004 05:33 PMSheesh. The numbers just isn't there for Gregorie folks.
Posted by: B.Huston on November 17, 2004 05:55 PMFor what it's worth, I think you all should get braced for some more King County votes.
This is a great web site.
Posted by: Tim B. on November 17, 2004 06:07 PMKing County just reported to Associated Press there are an additional 1074 ballots to be counted. Secretary of State’s office is being notified. Where will this all end! I smell a rat.
Comment by bruce chalmers— 11/17/04 @ 5:53 pm
Posted by: Ray on November 17, 2004 06:10 PMKing 5 News get state election totals before the people!
Is this state run by King County and King 5 News??
Disgusting!
That would be 457:Rossi and 293:Gregoire
Rossi would then win by 151 votes (-13 current difference + 164 from Benton County)
Rossi got 69.3% of the ballots already counted in Benton County so 61% seems doable
Posted by: John B on November 17, 2004 06:14 PMhttp://www.co.benton.wa.us/cgi-bin/wwwquery/election/showresults.qry?RACE=Governor
Posted by: John B on November 17, 2004 06:21 PMIf we get down into that even before the last county certifies and state certifies--we've got bigger problems than who becomes governor.
Posted by: Watkins on November 17, 2004 06:25 PMI think the last thing King County wants is a *hand* recount!
Posted by: Deborah on November 17, 2004 06:25 PM"A recount is the process where the counties simply re-tabulate all the ballots that were counted in the original count.
In the original count, final determinations are made by the county canvassing boards on what votes will be counted.
The recount does not allow a review of decisions by the county canvassing boards of what constitutes a vote.
Thus, the same ballots counted in the original count will simply be re-tabulated. "
Thus, there should not be hundreds of new uncounted ballots added to the count, even if it is a manual recount. If there are, then someone really screwed up in the first count, or something fishy is going on.
Posted by: Jim on November 17, 2004 06:33 PMIf only Murray had lost it would have been a perfect election, but hey we'll take it. Hopefully this ends with a simple recount and Rossi is in Olympia.
There's going to be a major house cleaning. Bureaucrats, begin squirming now.
Posted by: Jeff B on November 17, 2004 06:44 PMI'm just ecstatic! Absolutely overjoyed! Even my grumpy old man can't bully this joy outta me!
There's just nothing but joy in Skagino County!
Public records WILL be public records!
Taxes will be on a leash!
Government will be accountable TO THE PEOPLE!
If that's not enough, I don't know what is!
Posted by: Josef on November 17, 2004 07:04 PMThere are other expectations but my hopes are sky-high. I just want the long nightmare of Gridlocke-Gregoire scandalitis to end. At least Mike Lowry wasn't as bad.
If we can have moral government that'll hold state gov't accountable AND make the appropiate investments in our future where appropiate with tax increases if absolutely necessary - I'll be satisfied.
I wonder what the always pithy, always wordsmithy Marsha Louise Richards has to say for herself...
I also hope we're civil and sweet to our opponents. They put up a good fight and with few exceptions (mainly punks in Gregoire's HQ and Gregoire itself) fought cleanly. My hat's off to them. But I think it's over (pending recount).
Posted by: Josef on November 17, 2004 07:28 PM75,000 plus voters in WA who voted did not bother to vote for Governor. Race is at 261 votes.
I am 47 and have always voted downballot.
Studies have shown that the young and minorities tend not to vote as they go down the ballot.
Posted by: Ralph on November 17, 2004 07:30 PMMy husband and I plan to retire in either WA or ID (his family is from ID, mine from WA.) We plan to retire in 2011, or maybe a few years after that. We've conservative, and were thinking ID lately seeing how things were going in WA, but maybe there's hope for my home state!
Posted by: Elizabeth B on November 17, 2004 07:57 PMIf the recounts proceed like the last election with Cantwell, Gregoire picks up 290 extra and will win by 29. Gregoire is on track to win.
The count at this point has no meaning. One thing for sure is that Dino will not lead by 261 after the recount.
I leave to other bloggers who have done research in this or other states to see which way a recount will likely go.
The big question is can Gregoire order a hand recount only in King County.
Posted by: Erik on November 17, 2004 08:07 PMBUT, in all due fun and good humor with apologies if not taken that way: Mr. Bjornson, I think I may give you a call at (253) 272-1434 or e-mail you at Ebjornson@msn.com about filing a divorce... between Christine Gregoire and the Washington State Democratic Party.
Why?
Well, new reason 1: Anybody hear of Anne Bremner the Fox News analyst and ardent Gregoire defender? Guess what? "She’s an ardent backer of both Dubya (she donated $2,000 to his campaign at the Hunt’s Point fund-raiser last year) and Gregoire, a Democrat." SOURCE.
Or the fact that Democrats get in an uproar over Cheney hiding documents... while Democrats argue in court to blast holes in public records laws wide enough for a Nimitz-class Carrier to stride through.
Something Dinocrats and Rossi Republicans can joke about, eh??? Especially when I kept telling people that Gregoire was respectfully the Democratic characterization of Bush in a dress...
(I obviously mean this in good fun and apologize if anybody doesn't take it that way.)
Giggles plenty. Ha, ha, ha. Aren't we happy now?
That said, a concerning something to see: The conservative Building Industry Association of Washington uses insurance revenue from municipalities to help finance political activity
Posted by: Josef on November 17, 2004 08:48 PM2000 — United States Senate
Net Change: Democrat Cantwell + 276
2000 — Secretary of State
Net Change: Democrat Bonker +265
1968 — State Attorney General
Net Change: Democrat McCutcheon +604
HMMMMM- I SEE A PATTERN.... Adios Dino! Democrats will never let you be gov.
Posted by: Me on November 17, 2004 09:00 PMIn the meanwhile, let's please fix the BS with shaky-handed voters. What I saw in person this recent weekend was disappointing. Mail-in votes are great, because older people who can't get around vote. The same people have a harder time writing, and usually need someone like a nurse or staff person to fill in the ovals for them. Then their signature is required, and it might not match the records exactly.
When I submit my tax statements, there are places for the preparer to sign for the preparation work that was done. I think that we need to recognize in this state that we have essentially made a great thing legal -- off-site assisted ballots for the blind, elderly, hospitalized, and otherwise challenged but competent voter. We should keep this part of the system, but also keep a good, legal, track of who is doing the preparation. We all seem to want more transparency, daylight, and accountability in this process.
Rossi has already said it is important to him to speed this process up. That should be the last priority. Making this process fair, equal, accountable, transparent, and otherwise 'right' is what he should do.
Other issues we should fix:
- College students voted provisionally more often than made sense to me -- usually at the poll in their campus town, and not in the county where they had registered. We want to include and encourage new voters, and keep them voting, right?
- Letters from the County Auditor weren't very urgent-sounding, but if returned and received by the 16th, would re-instate a questioned ballot.
- Not enough voters understood who Gregoire is, and her record. (Hey, allow me some room to whine considering the outcome tonight.)
I'm sad to see Rossi's style of 'change' coming to our state. But at this point, I will at least give you that the odds are in his favor.
I would rather see a time-consuming and 2x expensive hand recount. I don't trust the computer systems, either. Again, where is the accountability? I trust the people farther than I could throw those computers.
Posted by: X on November 17, 2004 09:17 PMCongrats, Dino, from a Spokane voter!
Posted by: Brian on November 17, 2004 09:37 PMGoing into the election I expected an excellent new Attorney General in Rob McKenna, but I honestly didn't know what to expect in this race. After 20 years in the wilderness, as Dino has described it. He will surely shake things up in Olympia.
Some guys over at the Starbucks here in Green Lake were just whining about the results a second ago. But I gotta cut them some slack--I used to be a Democrat, too. They'll learn. In the meantime, we'll have an EXCELLENT GOVERNOR!
CONTRATULATIONS DINO ROSSI!!!
Posted by: Seth Cooper on November 17, 2004 10:15 PM"College students voted provisionally more often than made sense to me -- usually at the poll in their campus town, and not in the county where they had registered. We want to include and encourage new voters, and keep them voting, right?"
Yeah, when they could have gone absentee like this college kid. Crazy.
Posted by: Josef on November 17, 2004 10:16 PMHopefully, he will adopt the same measured approach to Olympia. We do need staff (sometimes called bureacrats) in Olympia to do the work. Leading them to be more productive will be the challenge and I think he'll be good at it. Be prepared for some squawking for Olympia is going to be uncomfortable after 20 years of predictability, but the citizens should stick to the measure of "Does It Make Washington Better?" as a yardstick?
Go Dino! You've got about 3 years to prove yourself.
Posted by: Matt on November 18, 2004 08:11 AMI overheard a Seattle "progressive" in the elevator:
"Those stupid bible-thumping farmers just don't understand what we're trying to do for them"
Actually, they understand perfectly...
Posted by: Bob on November 19, 2004 09:43 AM